Best Plush Cat Toys

High-quality, handmade plush toy that is assembled in the United States. Catnip lovers go crazy for it.

Plush toy is filled with organic catnip, so your cat will love playing with it and chewing on it. Has a variety of textures that will keep cats entertained and interested. Measures 7" long, so it's a perfect size for an adult cat. Durable, even if bitten often.

Costlier than some others. Cannot be refilled.

Best Bang for the Buck

A low price for a catnip plush toy that is the perfect size for the cat to bat, hold, or throw in the air.

Red color and shape of a hot pepper gives your cat a unique looking toy. Filled with catnip, so it will keep your fur-baby entertained. Excellent price point for a plush cat toy, especially considering its high-quality construction.

Softies Patchwork Bear Cuddle Plush Catnip Cat Toy

No option to refill the catnip. Might be too small for larger cats to enjoy.

KONG

Check Price

Trusted Brand

Contains both crinkle sounds and catnip inside to keep your cat interested in the toy.

Trusted brand name for pet toys, so you can count on the quality of the toy's construction. Extremely soft fabric makes it perfect for cuddle time. Fun shape, so cats can toss it around during play time.

May be a little large for a small cat or kitten. No option to refill the catnip.

When you want a plush cat toy that has an attention-grabbing look, this one fits the bill.

Adorable shrimp character looks cute with plenty of fun details. Contains a catnip packet inside to hold your cat's attention. Curved shape in the toy makes it easier for your cat to toss and bat around.

Squirrel Refillable Catnip Cat Toy

Cat could pull off the google eyes, damaging the toy. Catnip is not refillable.

Petlinks

Check Price

Best for Everyday Use

Excellent price for a fun plush toy that allows you to refill it with your kitty's favorite catnip.

Very soft fabrics used in the construction of the toy, so it's perfect for cuddle time. Catnip inside the toy will keep kitties entertained and engaged. Multiple textures make it appealing to cats. Good price, and it ships with extra catnip.

Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy

Very small plush toy. Not made to stand up to rough play.

Why trust BestReviews?

BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We only make money if you purchase a product through our links, and all opinions about the products are our own. About BestReviews

BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing, and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. We buy all products with our own funds, and we never accept free products from manufacturers.About BestReviews

HOW WE TESTED

We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that's designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter, to bring you these selections.

Click here for testing insights

Models
Considered

Consumers
Consulted

Hours
Researched

Written by Kyle Schurman

Updated June 2023

Plush cat toys provide a great way to keep your cat entertained, whether you're not around or are tossing it to them. These toys also provide a means for allowing the cat to exercise. Whether your cat is batting the plush toy, hugging it, or chewing on it, it will have fun. Many plush toys for cats will be filled with catnip, which keeps the animal engaged and has a relaxing effect after playtime with it. They also may create noises like crinkles or may have different textures, which cats love. A good plush toy for cats will have a soft exterior with no sharp edges. It also will feel soft when squeezed, yet hold up to chewing. Cat plush toys come in all shapes and sizes, and they often resemble small animals.

Get emails you’ll love.

Learn about the products you’re wondering if you should buy and get advice on using your latest purchases.

Our Top Picks

Best of the Best

Yeowww!

High-quality, handmade plush toy that is assembled in the United States. Catnip lovers go crazy for it.

Best Bang for the Buck

OurPets

Hot Stuff Cat Toy

A low price for a catnip plush toy that is the perfect size for the cat to bat, hold, or throw in the air.

Softies Patchwork Bear Cuddle Plush Catnip Cat Toy

Top Pick

KONG

Contains both crinkle sounds and catnip inside to keep your cat interested in the toy.

When you want a plush cat toy that has an attention-grabbing look, this one fits the bill.

Squirrel Refillable Catnip Cat Toy

Top Pick

Petlinks

Excellent price for a fun plush toy that allows you to refill it with your kitty's favorite catnip.